The scissor jack in your trunk is fine for exactly one thing: a flat tire on the side of the road when you have no other choice. It is not fine for rotating tires in your own garage, and it is not fine for any job that asks you to get under the truck. I spent 30 years turning wrenches professionally, and I keep a BIG RED 3 ton floor jack in my garage for every job the factory jack was never meant to do. Here are ten reasons it earns its spot next to my rolling tool chest.
Stop Fighting the Factory Jack
One hydraulic floor jack replaces every frustrating minute you have spent cranking a scissor jack on cold pavement. Leave the trunk jack for emergencies and get a tool that actually works.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →It Lifts the Whole Truck, Not One Corner
A scissor jack lifts a single corner just high enough to swap a tire. A 3 ton floor jack with 6,000 lb of capacity picks up the entire front or rear of my F-150 without straining. That means both tires off at once, which turns a tire rotation from a two-hour fight into a forty-minute job. Last October I rotated all four tires and checked the brakes in one sitting, and I never once had to move the jack. You stop working around the jack and start working on the truck.
It Gets the Truck High Enough to Actually Work
The scissor jack barely clears the tire. The BIG RED 3 ton floor jack raises the frame high enough that I can slide a jack stand under it and still have room to reach the oil drain plug without lying flat on my back. When you are 57 with a bad knee, that extra foot of clearance is the difference between doing the job yourself and paying someone else to do it. I measured it one afternoon: the frame sits about 19 inches off the ground on the floor jack, versus maybe 12 with the scissor jack. That seven inches is where the whole job gets easier.
It Rolls Where You Need It
A scissor jack has to be positioned perfectly before you start cranking, because it does not move once it touches the frame. A floor jack rolls on casters, so I can nudge it into the exact lift point while it is still on the ground. That sounds like a small thing until you have lain on cold concrete trying to align a scissor jack in the dark. With a floor jack, the lift point finds you. I line up the saddle under the front subframe, give the handle one small push, and it settles right where it needs to be before I pump it up.
It Does the Heavy Lifting for You
The whole point of a hydraulic jack is that you pump the handle a few times instead of cranking a threaded rod forty turns. The BIG RED floor jack uses the truck's own weight to do most of the work. My wife Diane has used it to lift the front of the F-150 by herself, which tells you how little effort it takes. She had the front end up in about a dozen pumps, and she is not trying to prove anything to anyone. That is the difference between a tool and a workout.
It Is Stable on Concrete
A scissor jack has a narrow footprint and a high center of gravity once it is loaded. A floor jack sits low and wide, so the truck feels solid on it. I still always set jack stands before I go under any vehicle, but the floor jack gives me a stable platform while I position them. When you are reaching under a 6,000 lb truck, stable is not a luxury. It is the whole point. I have had the truck up on the BIG RED jack with both front wheels off and never once felt the frame shift when I leaned on a breaker bar.
It Works on the Trailers and the Mower Too
The scissor jack only fits the pinch welds on a car. The BIG RED 3 ton floor jack has a wide saddle that works on the frame of my utility trailer, the front axle of the lawn mower, and the I-beam on the little tractor my neighbor and I use for fence posts. Last spring I used it to lift the trailer so I could repack both wheel bearings, and the saddle sat right on the axle tube without any adapter. One jack in the garage covers everything with wheels, and that is worth more than any single tool purchase I have made in years.
It Makes Brake Jobs a One-Person Job
With the whole front end off the ground, I can pull both front wheels, do the pads and rotors, and put everything back without ever moving the jack. The scissor jack would mean lifting, lowering, repositioning, and lifting again for each wheel. The floor jack does it in one setup. When you work alone in a garage, anything that removes a step from the job is worth keeping around. I did the front brakes on the F-150 in about two hours on a Saturday morning, and the only time I touched the jack was to set it and lower it when I was done.
It Saves Your Back
Cranking a scissor jack is a lot of bending and kneeling. Pumping a floor jack handle is standing work. After a full day of brake pads and an oil change, my back knows the difference. That alone is worth the garage space it takes up. I did not buy the floor jack for the speed or the convenience. I bought it because I want to keep working on my own truck for another twenty years. The day I brought it home, I did an oil change just to see how it felt, and I was done before my back even noticed I had been working.
It Is There When the Scissor Jack Gives Up
Scissor jacks are built to a price and they wear out. I have seen the threads strip and the pivot pins bend on more than one factory jack. A BIG RED 3 ton floor jack is a solid piece of equipment rated for 6,000 lb, and it does not care how many times a year I use it. Mine has been in the garage for years and still holds the truck up like the day I bought it. I keep it on the same spot on the concrete floor, and it has never leaked a drop of fluid or lost a pump. That is the kind of reliability that earns trust.
It Pays for Itself in One Weekend
The first time you use a floor jack to rotate your own tires, you have already made back most of what it costs versus paying a shop. Do that four times a year, plus one brake job, and the BIG RED jack has paid for itself before the first winter is over. That is the kind of math I understand. The scissor jack costs you nothing, and it is worth exactly that once you start doing real work. I figure I have done six tire rotations and two brake jobs with mine in the last year alone, and that is six trips to the shop I did not have to make.
What I'd Skip
If you only ever drive a small sedan and you have never changed your own oil, you can skip the floor jack. The scissor jack will get you through the one flat tire you see every few years, and the trunk space is worth more to you than the convenience. But the moment you start doing your own maintenance, or you drive a full-size truck, the factory jack stops being a tool and starts being an obstacle. That is the moment to buy the floor jack. Keep the scissor jack in the trunk where it belongs, and let the floor jack earn its keep in the garage.
I have seen the threads strip and the pivot pins bend on more than one factory jack. The BIG RED has held my F-150 up for years without a complaint.
Keep the Scissor Jack for the Side of the Road
Leave the factory jack in the trunk for emergencies. Keep a BIG RED 3 ton floor jack in the garage for everything else, and you will wonder why you waited so long.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →